The Swiss Origins of Europe’s Witch Hunts: How Simmental’s Trials Sparked a Continental Craze

Switzerland’s Forgotten Role in the Witch Craze

The European witch hunts of the early modern period remain one of history’s darkest and most misunderstood chapters. While most associate these persecutions with Salem, Germany, or Scotland, few realize that one of the earliest recorded witch trials took place in Simmental, Switzerland, in the early 1400s.

This Swiss case set a chilling precedent, introducing legal and theological concepts that would shape the systematic persecution of alleged witches across Europe. But how did an obscure valley in the Bernese Oberland become a template for mass hysteria? What political, religious, and social forces converged to turn superstition into deadly trials?

By examining the historical evidence, scholarly debates, and wider context of the Simmental trials, we can uncover how a seemingly small event spiraled into a continent-wide obsession with eradicating witches.

The First Sparks of the European Witch Craze

The Simmental Witch Trial of 1400: A Blueprint for Persecution

The origins of the European witch craze can be traced back to a remote valley in Switzerland. In the year 1400, the Simmental region saw one of the first recorded witch trials in history.

According to contemporary accounts, the trial revolved around a man from the village of Boltigen, who was accused of practicing sorcery. The charges against him included:

• Causing Miscarriages: Women in the village claimed that he had cursed them, leading to stillbirths.
• Destroying Crops and Livestock: Farmers reported that their cattle had fallen ill and their fields had been ruined.
• Making a Pact with the Devil: Under torture, the accused confessed to having sold his soul to Satan in exchange for magical powers.

But this trial was not an isolated case of superstition leading to execution. What made it different was how it introduced key elements that would define future witch trials, including the idea that witches operated within secret sects and that their magic was inherently tied to demonic influence.

The execution of the accused witches in Simmental marked the beginning of a legal and ideological shift—one that would escalate into mass witch hunts across Europe over the next few centuries.

The Book That Spread the Panic: Johannes Nider’s Formicarius

How a 15th-Century Theological Text Justified Witch Persecutions

One of the main reasons why the Simmental trial became so influential was that it was documented by Johannes Nider, a German Dominican theologian.

Around 1430, Nider wrote Formicarius, a book intended as a theological guide but which contained some of the earliest detailed accounts of organized witchcraft. In it, he described the Simmental case, portraying it as evidence of a growing Satanic conspiracy.

Why Was Formicarius So Important?

1. It Linked Witches to the Devil – Before this period, witchcraft had often been seen as superstition or folklore. Formicarius helped redefine witches as agents of Satan, making their prosecution a religious necessity.
2. It Influenced Later Witch-Hunting Manuals – The infamous Malleus Maleficarum (1487), written by Heinrich Kramer, borrowed heavily from Nider’s ideas and became the primary guide for witch hunters across Europe.
3. It Spread the Idea of the Witches’ Sabbath – Nider’s descriptions of secret gatherings where witches supposedly engaged in devil worship would become a central theme in later witch trials.

Without Formicarius, the Simmental trial might have faded into history as a local case of paranoia. Instead, it became a model for future inquisitors looking for “evidence” of witchcraft in their own regions.

Fact or Fiction? The Historical Debate Over Simmental’s Witch Trials

Did the Simmental Witch Hunts Actually Happen?

Despite the widespread influence of the Simmental case, modern historians question whether the events actually occurred as described.

One of the main issues is that Nider’s Formicarius is the only primary source documenting the trial. No official legal records from Simmental have survived, leading some scholars to suggest that:

• The trial was exaggerated to serve religious or political narratives.
• Elements were invented to reinforce the Church’s growing obsession with demonology.
• The accused may have been victims of local conflicts, rather than actual practitioners of witchcraft.

The timing of the trial is also suspicious—occurring just as the Catholic Church was increasing its use of the Inquisition to root out perceived threats to its authority. If nothing else, the Simmental case reveals how witch trials could be manipulated for ideological purposes, a trend that would continue for centuries.

Why Switzerland Became a Hotspot for Early Witch Hunts

The Role of the Inquisition and Political Instability

While witch trials occurred across Europe, Switzerland saw some of the earliest and most intense persecutions. But why?

1. The Presence of the Inquisition: The Catholic Church’s campaign against heresy was already well-established in Switzerland by the early 15th century.
2. Papal Decrees Targeting Sorcery: In 1409, Pope Alexander V issued orders instructing inquisitors to act against “forbidden rites.” This gave authorities the legal backing to prosecute alleged witches.
3. Local Political Conflicts: During this period, Switzerland was undergoing territorial disputes and social unrest. Witch trials may have been used as a means of controlling rebellious regions.

The Simmental trial set the stage for future Swiss witch hunts, such as the massive Valais trials of 1428, which saw hundreds of executions.

The Long-Lasting Impact of the Simmental Witch Hunts

From Swiss Courts to Continental Persecution

The ideas that emerged from the Simmental case continued to shape European witch trials for centuries. Some of the most infamous persecutions that followed included:

• The Bamberg and Würzburg Witch Trials (1626–1631) – One of the largest mass executions of alleged witches in Germany.
• The Scottish Witch Trials (16th–17th centuries) – Inspired by similar theological ideas about Satanic pacts and conspiracies.
• The Salem Witch Trials (1692) – Though in America, these trials followed many of the legal precedents first established in Europe.

By the end of the 18th century, witch trials began to fade, as skepticism and Enlightenment thinking replaced medieval superstitions. But the scars left by this history remain.

Lessons from Simmental’s Dark Past

The Simmental witch hunts serve as a cautionary tale about the dangers of fear, misinformation, and mass hysteria. Whether exaggerated or not, this trial helped establish the legal and ideological framework for centuries of witch persecutions across Europe.

Today, historians continue to reevaluate this dark chapter, with some Swiss communities even working to rehabilitate the names of executed witches. Understanding the political and social forces behind these trials is crucial—not just for historical curiosity, but for recognizing how similar patterns of persecution still emerge in modern societies.

By learning from the past, we can work toward a future where justice is not dictated by fear, and reason triumphs over superstition.

Want to explore more forgotten history? Subscribe to our blog for in-depth historical insights!